Real Pinot for Pinot People
Friday, October 3, 2008 at 11:33AM Todd Hamina is an opinionated winemaker. Like all opinionated winemakers he can be controversial. He also happens to be making some outstanding wines. This should not be surprising as the politically correct usually make politically correct wines, which is just as boring in the wine world as it is in the real world. Todd had a solid winemaking foundation moving through important Oregon cellars such as Patton Valley and Maysara before founding his own label, Biggio Hamina, with the 2007 vintage. The results of that education are evident in his new wines.
Those of us who cut our teeth on European wines many decades ago often accept today's supercharged wines with grudging respect and wistful memory of those more elegant, balanced wines of our past. I ran into Todd today and tasted some of his first releases and I can only say that I was blown away by his wines, which took me back to a day when wines lived by verve not power.
I was so impressed with Todd's wines that I bought two bottles almost out of disbelief. When I retasted them with my dinner I liked them even better than I did before. These are genuine wines made without regard to current fashion that were only guided by the vision of the winemaker and nature. Love them or hate them they're Todd's wines, a personal statement. I loved them.
The 2007 Biggio Hamina Melon de Bourgogne, Deux Vert Vineyard just astounded me. Firm and bright with zinging minerality and a long clean, truly dry finish, this is the first American Melon that I've tasted that will actually remind wine drinkers of the great wines of Muscadet, where the only really great examples of this variety have been produced. When I tasted this wine, from the excellent Deux Vert vineyard in the Yamhill Carlton AVA, I could only think what a shame it is that these fine grapes have been wasted in previous vintages by less thoughtful winemakers, but I'm thrilled that someone is now finally taking proper care of them. I would confidently show this wine to the most devoted Muscadet drinker.
The 2007 Biggio Hamina Willamette Valley Pinot Noir is nothing short of a profile in winemaking courage as few have the guts to make real pinot these days. This is real pinot noir for real pinot noir drinkers. Those that prefer pinot that tastes more like syrah won't like this wine and should leave it for the those that love pinot for its natural, refined personality. The color is a delicate, inviting translucent garnet. It's rare to see pinot this color anywhere these days and I applaud Todd's courage to let real pinot characteristics show through in his wines. Pinot does not naturally have a lot of color and you can bet the dark wines you see these days are made by some sort of cheat. Enzymes or other varieties are all to often used to add an unnatural depth of color to pinot noir. If you can't read through a glass of pinot, something is amiss. The nose is lifting and fresh with earthy truffle and orange zest spice layered over lively bitter cherry fruit. The finish is long and clean. I could only think of excellent pinots from lesser Burgundy appellations like Marsannay and Fixin when I drank this beauty.
Both of these wines are an astounding 12.5% alcohol, which makes them almost freaks these days. Tasting wines like this makes you realize what a critical issue alcohol is as you can taste so much more in these wines simply because all the nuance is not overwhelmed by alcohol. For delicate varieties like pinot this issue has gone out of control as high-alcohol pinots are just boring and pointless to drink because they don't taste like pinot anymore. If you want a big wine get something from a big variety like syrah, not a delicate variety like pinot.
Another astounding fact about these wines is that they are also both $20 or less a bottle. I know, like you, I thought such wines did not exist in America. Actually for all practical purposes they don't, but now at least two do. Hopefully, soon there will be a lot more.
Todd will be releasing some single vineyard pinot noirs, syrah and pinot blanc from the 2007 vintage and I can't wait to taste them. If these wines are any indicator they should be something very special indeed.











Reader Comments (15)
I am going to try a mixed case of Biggio Hamina wines on the strength of your comments - which tells you two things: 1) I trust your palate, and 2) I am desparate for wines that don't pump up the alcohol.
Best, Jim
I have to take some issue with your statement; "If you can't read through a glass of pinot, something is amiss." You do so in the context that, I read as, insinuating any pinot noir with deep colors is somehow the result of 'enological hocus pocus'.
I certainly agree that these measures are often employed but not ALL dark, richly colored Pinot Noirs are the result of there use. There are still plenty of winemakers that don't manipulate a wines color.
Thank you for the tremendously positive write up, I appreciate it. The response to the wines so far has been quite promising, which is nice as we have a bunch of fruit to pay for in the next little bit.
My opinion is that 07 was not a year to do a big boy style (which is fine with me), and it looks like 08 could move in that trend as well.
Jerry, if you cold soak, ferment over 90 degrees F, and use over 40% new oak then you most assuredly are manipulating a wines color, regardless if you are adding enzymes or tannins. Either way they all result in darker wines.
I fermented in the high 70's and low 80's, utilized tons of whole cluster (which robs color) and didn't buy too many new barrels. I figure I'm paying for grapes... I will try to push the envelope in the direction of delicacy. You should be able to read through a glass of pinot noir, no doubt.
I will take brilliant clarity over dark color every time.
Cheers,
Todd
Currently we are in Oregon (mainly, as we self distribute), Idaho, Wyoming and Northern California. Beginning work on Seattle, Utah and NYC, but they could take time. We're little and will have zero leverage in those markets. I suspect the economic slow down to have an effect on new market entries. We'll see.
Thanks for the interest.
I am of the opinion that you get better wines with old wood. It seems nothing is lost as far as oxygen permability goes and one doesn't get that overlay of wood smells and flavors that tends to obscure the wine - and in the worst of cases, alter it forever.
I'm not saying wine should be just fruity; IMO it should reflect its place and hopefully carry enough soil markers that one can say with some degree of credibility, that it is of its place.
I applaud winemakers who shoot for this goal and who keep the alcohols under control. Nothing can change the basic textures and profile of a wine quicker than big alcohols and new wood.
Best, Jim
So far I have had the Willamette Valley, Deux Vert Vineyard and Montazi Vineyard Pinot's.
I will agree with Craig on the Willamette Valley. It was a good wine, and a good value at $24, but the other two had a distinct "nuevo beaujolais" taste and feel to them, the Deux Vert Vineyard more so than the Montazi.
It may be the 2007's are a little too young to drink right now, and could benefit from some more bottle aging, or I am a victim of bottle variation, but what ever the case, so far I have been a little disappointed.
Comments anyone?
Still I was very surprised how different the two vineyard designated Pinot's where compared to the Willamette Valley Pinot. At the very least, I expected them to be just as good (or better), considering the wine making process is the same for all of the wines.
I believe in bottle shock and the positive note from Marc's experience is that I am telling my customers to wait a month after shipping to let the bottles get their groove back.
Had I known of Marc's great thirst, maybe things would have been different.
Cheers